
Carmel-by-the-Sea Design Review for Homes and Additions
Plans drawn for the City’s Design Study process, from the first site assessment to the Planning Commission.
In Carmel-by-the-Sea, the design review step decides what can be built long before the building permit. Whether you are replacing a cottage, adding a primary suite or reworking a whole house, the City looks at size, massing, trees, privacy and fit with the neighborhood. We draw plans for that process and keep the design pointed at what the City’s rules and guidelines ask for.
Track One and Track Two
The City runs two residential Design Study tracks for homes in the R-1 district. Track One is a staff-level review for projects that need no coastal development permit and are exempt from a public hearing; staff check the zoning standards and the residential design guidelines. Track Two is for projects that need a public hearing before the Planning Commission. It starts with a Preliminary Site Assessment, followed by design concept plans and then final plans. Current guidelines and handouts are on the City’s Planning page.
The Preliminary Site Assessment
Under the City’s design review code (Chapter 17.58), a site assessment comes before design plans for all new construction, demolitions, grading over 25 cubic yards, additions that increase building coverage by more than 200 square feet or 10 percent, and any work that grades near, cuts or removes trees the City Forester rates significant or moderately significant. You submit a topographic survey by a licensed surveyor or civil engineer showing boundaries, contours, every tree over 2 inches in diameter, existing structures, easements and site coverage. The City Forester and the City Planner then walk the site and mark up that survey: tree health and significance, limbs and root zones to avoid, and the street and neighborhood patterns the design should respond to. For buildings 50 years or older without a current historic determination, a deposit for a historic evaluation is also required.
Designing for the review
Because the Forester and Planner notes come first, we start design from the marked-up survey rather than from a wish list. Trees and root zones set the buildable area, neighborhood patterns guide height, materials and setbacks, and the massing is sized for the Commission’s questions about privacy, views and scale. Projects heard by the Commission are commonly shown with story poles, so we plan rooflines that read well on the lot.
How a Carmel project moves with us
- Lot and house check: zoning, coverage, height, trees, age of the house and which track applies.
- Survey and site assessment: we coordinate the topographic survey and use the Forester and Planner notes.
- Concept plans: site plan, floor plans, elevations and massing for review.
- Final design set: materials, colors, landscape and lighting as the City asks.
- Building set: construction drawings with engineering and Title 24 energy. See what is in a permit set.
- Construction: our sister company Harrod Built can give costing during design and bid the build.
Our work
We are a Paso Robles design office. The homes in our portfolio are in San Luis Obispo County; we have none to show in Carmel-by-the-Sea yet. Under California Business and Professions Code 5537, a designer like us may prepare plans for wood-frame homes of up to two stories plus a basement. Licensed engineers design and stamp the structure, soils and grading work, and we bring in the surveyor, septic designer or other licensed professionals each agency asks for. Related: custom home plans in Carmel-by-the-Sea, addition plans in Carmel-by-the-Sea, remodel plans in Carmel-by-the-Sea, home design in Carmel-by-the-Sea, Monterey County.
Questions we hear
What is a Design Study in Carmel-by-the-Sea?
It is the City’s residential design review for homes in the single-family (R-1) district. Track One is a staff-level review for projects that need no coastal permit and no public hearing. Track Two goes to a public hearing before the Planning Commission.
Does my addition need a Preliminary Site Assessment?
Under the City’s design review code, a site assessment comes before design plans for new construction, demolitions, grading over 25 cubic yards, additions that add more than 200 square feet or 10 percent of building coverage, and work near or removing trees the City Forester rates significant or moderately significant.
Why does the City Forester visit my lot?
The Forester looks at every tree on the site and in the right-of-way, classifies each one, and notes limbs and root zones to avoid. Those notes shape where a new house or addition can go.
What survey do I need?
Two copies of a topographic survey by a licensed surveyor or civil engineer, showing boundaries, contours, every tree over 2 inches in diameter, existing structures, easements and site coverage.
Can Harrod Built price the work during design?
Yes. Our sister company Harrod Built can give construction costing during design and bid the build.
Design and build with one family
We design with real construction costs in mind. Our sister company Harrod Built can give you costing during design and build the home, and Paso Robles Landscaping can handle the pool, hardscape and planting. Same family, same Paso Robles office.
Get a quote for Carmel-by-the-Sea design review plans
Send the address and a short note on the house, remodel or addition you have in mind, plus any existing plans. Call 805-712-8993, or reach us on the contact page.